Showing posts sorted by date for query proof positive. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query proof positive. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Tuesday, April 01, 2014

DHECC - Samples? Possibly....Random? Not likely.

Last Friday I received a tip from an anon that the blacked-out claim on the email from PSC attorney Calvin Fayard to Christine Reitano is for a company called Fab-Worx in Hammond, LA.  This is of great importance because Fab-Worx just happens to be owned by Fayard's cousin and business partner in multiple businesses, Robert A. Maurin, III.

While I haven't been able find any direct ownership on Fayard's part with Fab-Worx, the company name has multiple filings with the Louisiana Secretary of State and I'm unable to ascertain which company with "Fab-worx" in the name may have filed a claim with the DHECC.

There is a Hammond-based Fab-Worx Holding, LLC that was registered in 2011 which would put the company's incorporation date after the Deepwater Horizon accident and nullify their ability to file a claim but then there is another filing called Fab-Worx Properties, L.l.C., that was registered from a Baton Rouge location in 2008.

I am slowly uncovering multiple business ventures between Calvin Fayard and Robert Maurin, as well as ventures between his daughter and lawyer at his firm, Caroline Fayard, and Maurin.

The fact that Fayard had this particular claim expedited calls into question Patrick Juneau's explanation that the claims listed in the email chain were being used as part of a "sampling program".  If that's the case, and this blacked-out claim is indeed Fab-Worx, then we can assume the "samples" chosen were not random.  Unless Fayard randomly plucked his cousin's claim out of a hat.

Last night I faxed the following letter to Special Master Louis Freeh asking him to please investigate this matter while cc'ing the Court, Fayard and other various legal entities:

Special Master Louis Freeh,

Hello, my name is Jason Berry and I am the investigative journalist who authors The American Zombie blog here in New Orleans, La.  As you may know, I have been writing about issues that have occurred within the Deepwater Horizon Economic Claims Center since it’s inception, particularly specific members of the attorneys appointed as class counsel to the settlement, the Plaintiff Steering Committee.  

Recently, I posted a report based on information I anonymously received in the mail that confirmed an allegation I have been researching for over a year that the PSC members had expedited their own claims ahead of other class members’ claims with the knowledge and consent of the the Claims Administrator, Patrick Juneau.  

Upon publishing the story, Mr. Juneau replied to the me via email with the following explanation:

“In response to your recent inquiry, we thought that you should be made aware of the actual facts. In the fall of 2012 the DHECC Program was fast approaching the fairness hearing and the opt-out deadline.  To avoid confusion as to who should opt-out versus who should stay in the class, it was important for the class as a whole to have a representative sample of paid claims across all of the claim types in order for them to assess which was the better path forward for them.  This could not be accomplished in the time required using the first-in/first-out (FIFO) method outlined in the Settlement Agreement, which method had been used for the summer of 2012, because many of the claims were incomplete and therefore not ready for processing.

After discussion with the Court, BP and the PSC, it was determined that a larger number of claims should be examined before the fairness hearing so that the Court, the parties, objectors and claimants could see how the settlement program was working.  As noted above, since the program had encountered problems with a lot of the claims not having complete documentation it was difficult to come up with claims that could be analyzed and determined, so a sample of sufficiently documented claims was needed.

The Claims Administrator, with the knowledge and input of the PSC and BP, asked the PSC to provide a listing of such cases and a sampling was taken of those cases.  This action had nothing to do with trying to expedite a claim for any particular attorney or party. Pursuant to that request, claims were submitted, a sampling taken and determinations were made, and those results were made available to the Court and the parties at the time of the fairness hearing.  During this same time frame some of the objectors were taking the position that in order to be able to determine whether or not to opt out, they needed to see at the time of the fairness hearing a determination on the type of claims they were handling.  We therefore took samples of claims from the several of the objectors and made determinations which were also available at the time of the fairness hearing.  It is interesting to note that over 60% of the claims that were considered were not represented by the PSC. 

The issues as they stood at that time and the above outline of facts are supported by the e-mails recently made public which were subject to confidentiality.”

I have since filed a request (enclosed) with Mr. Juneau to provide me with the following:

“In the spirit of transparency of the claims process to the public it serves, I once again implore that you please provide me with a copy of (or the court record document number to) all orders, minute entries, and transcripts of each hearing, conference and telephone call (including conference calls) between and among you, the Administrator, and/or anyone on behalf of the DHECC or CAO, the PSC, BP representatives, and most importantly the Court, for each “discussion” you referenced in your response to my story.”

I subsequently contacted representatives from BP to verify that they were aware of the expedited claims.   BP’s Head of Communications Geoff Morrell replied to Mr. Juneau’s comments with the following comment:

“BP was aware of efforts by the Claims Administrator in the Fall of 2012 to get the CSSP up and running, including how to make the claims process more efficient and, correspondingly, increase the amount of claim payments in advance of the final approval hearing in November 2012.

However, there are other aspects of your blog postings -- including the e-mails from PSC members to the Claims Administrator you present -- that BP was not aware of, but  we are concerned about them and are trying to look into them now.”

Judging from Mr. Morrell’s response, it appears BP may not have been aware that the PSC attorneys and Mr. Juneau had expedited their own claims as part of the suggested “sampling program”.

Since writing this story, another matter has been brought to my attention which I believe is great cause for concern regarding the ethical matters of the expedited claims.  I have been told that the claim Mr. Calvin Fayard had expedited in the email, with Mr. Juneau’s knowledge and consent, may have been for a construction (it may not be construction depending on which company filed the claim) company owned by Mr. Juneau’s (I made this mistake in the original letter but sent a corrective letter shortly after) Mr Fayard's cousin,  Robert A. Maurin, III.  The company’s name is called Fab-Worx  and is based in Hammond, LA.  

Here is the email which details the request to expedite the claim:


Please note, there is no mention of a “sampling process” in this email exchange nor have I been able to find any mention of this process in the Fairness Hearing transcript which occurred in November of 2012, one month after the above email exchange.

As a reporter, I do not have access to claimant information and as the claim number was blacked out in the documents I received, I have no way of verifying if the above claim was indeed for Fab-Worx.  

However, you do have that access as a Special Master and investigator of the DHECC.  You also have access to the above email and the other emails I posted in my original story which can be found at the following URL:

http://www.theamericanzombie.com/2014/03/dhecc-proof-positive-of-claims-being.html

I believe this issue is of the utmost importance in respect to your ongoing investigation into alleged improprieties within the Claims Office.  If a PSC attorney was expediting his own relative’s claims above the rest of the class claims this is a clear violation of the laws of the settlement as dictated by Judge Carl J. Barbier:

“New claims may be filed during the Transition Process until such time as the Court Supervised Claims Program is established and operational as set forth above. New claims submitted shall be processed and evaluated in the order they are received. Non-deficient claims previously pending with the GCCF shall be processed and evaluated prior to any new claims filed after the creation of the Transition Process.”

The fact that this may have been a nepotistic effort for Mr. Fayard to enrich his own relative and possibly even himself by expediting his cousin’s claim is of profound importance to the public.  I believe the matter deserves investigation on your part to ensure  the claims process is being run equitably.  I trust you will pursue this matter as vigorously as you did the Thonn claim which involved the Andry Lerner Law Firm, Lionel Sutton, and Christine Reitano.  

In order to help your investigation, I have obtained some documents from the Louisiana Secretary of State database that show joint business ventures between Mr. Calvin Fayard and his cousin, Mr. Robert A. Maurin, III.  I also have found business relationships between Calvin Faryard’s daughter and member of his law firm, Caroline Fayard, and  Mr. Maurin.  I am enclosing these business filings:

Fab-Worx business filings:



Wiliston Oil and Gas (joint venture between Robert Maurin and Calvin Fayard):





Safari Investments (joint venture between Robert Maurin and Caroline Fayard):




I trust this information will help you in your investigation into the problems occurring within the DHECC and you will pursue this matter as vigorously as you did the Andry/Lerner, Sutton, Reitano, Thonn matter.  

Thank you for your consideration and please contact me if I can be of assistance on the matter.

Sincerely,



Jason Berry, Independent, Investigative Reporter,
(504) 975-3922

cc:  The Honorable Carl J. Barbier
The Honorable Sally Shushan
Kenneth A. Polite, Jr, U.S. Attorney
Charles B. Plattsmier, Office of the Disciplinary Counsel
John G. Heyburn II, Chairman, Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation
Calvin C. Fayard, Esq.

I am still researching the web of companies tying the Fayards and Maurin together.

I would like to ask any anon. who may be able to identify the claim number blacked-out in the email or any anon. who may have direct information identifying which claim Fayard had expedited, please email me or make an anonymous comment with the information.

Thanks.

Monday, March 31, 2014

DHECC - Lerner files for discovery on expedited claims

Today Glen Lerner filed a motion for discovery with Judge Barbier's court to obtain any information regarding the expedited claims that were revealed in my blog post from March 11:

American Zombie: DHECC - Proof positive of claims being expedited by the PSC

The motion specifically names the blog and the emails made public in the post:

Lerner Motion for Discovery Regarding Expedited Claims

I actually made a similar request (not legal) of Claims Administrator Patrick Juneau last week:
"It has been eleven days since I made this request for the minute entry and I have received no response from your office. 
In the spirit of transparency of the claims process to the public it serves, I once again implore that you please provide me with a copy of (or the court record document number to) all orders, minute entries, and transcripts of each hearing, conference and telephone call (including conference calls) between and among you, the Administrator, and/or anyone on behalf of the DHECC or CAO, the PSC, BP representatives, and most importantly the Court, for each “discussion” you referenced in your response to my story. 
Thank you and I look forward to receiving the records and/or document numbers within a reasonable time frame of fifteen days from today, March 26, 2014.  If you are unable to provide me with the requested public documents or references to public documents,  please respond to me with an explanation as to why the request can not be fulfilled."

Obviously the request has so far gone unanswered.  I hope Lerner has more luck with the Court.

I also received some interesting information and an allegation from an anon. regarding a specific claim mentioned in one of the emails last Friday.  Tonight, I informed Special Master Louis Freeh and the Court of the information and asked Freeh to launch an investigation into the matter.  I faxed the info. and I would like to give them time to read it tomorrow.   I will post on it later on in the day.

Tuesday, March 11, 2014

DHECC - Proof positive of claims being expedited by the PSC

For the past year and a half I've been reporting on issues that have occurred with the BP oil spill multi-district litigation settlement and the Claims Office of the Deepwater Horizon Economics Claims Center (DHECC).

From the beginning, I was approached by multiple sources that made claims of fraud and manipulation within the DHECC process.  Most of the allegations involved issues that were instigated by members of the Plaintiff Steering Committee (PSC)....the lawyers chosen to represent all the class claimants along the Gulf Coast in their lawsuit against BP.

Typically...frustratingly..... almost every one of my sources refused to go on the record and I've had a difficult time providing hard proof of the allegations.

My luck changed last week.

Allegations

There are two main issues I've been researching regarding the misconduct of specific PSC members:

1.  The allegation that some PSC firms sold access to the claim "formula" before the claims office opened.  In fact, it now appears some of the PSC firms entered into joint venture agreements with other law firms around the Gulf Coast without disclosing the nature of their involvement to either the claimants or the claims office.

2.  That members of the PSC had their own private claims expedited before other claimants who had filed ahead of them.

The Rules of the Settlement

Before I get to the evidence, I want to point out again that by order of Federal Judge Carl Barbier, the claims which come into the DHECC must be processed in the order they are received:

10.  New claims may be filed during the Transition Process until such time as the Court Supervised Claims Program is established and operational as set forth above. New claims submitted shall be processed and evaluated in the order they are received. Non-deficient claims previously pending with the GCCF shall be processed and evaluated prior to any new claims filed after the creation of the Transition Process.

A Breach of the Settlement?

Last week, I received an unmarked envelope in the mail that contained a series of email exchanges between employees of the Claims Office and other DHECC officials.  Among those involved in the conversation included Claims Administrator Pat Juneau, court vendor Brown and Greer, and members of the PSC.

These emails clearly suggest that PSC members were not only expediting their own claims, they were actually issuing directives to the employees of the Claims Office.  In fact, it looks like they were even holding back specific claims from being processed for political reasons.

Keep in mind the PSC lawyers are supposed to be representing all the claimants in this settlement process, not just their own personal clients.

Trying to get answers

A year ago in March of 2013, I filed a FOIA request with the DHECC in an effort to find out if any PSC members had expedited their own claims within the office.  My request was denied:

A little help

After the denial, I drafted a personal letter to Judge Barbier asking him to redact claimants' private information and make the claim data public so the public could be assured the process was operating according to the standards he had ordered:

The DHECC - Examining the "Claims" - Part 1

Judge Barbier never responded to my letter.

I made contact today with the Claims Office and requested an interview with Claims Administrator Pat Juneau.  My interview request was denied but he did agree to provide statements and facts to any questions I had.  I responded by asking him (via email) if he was aware of any claims that may have been expedited in the office, particularly ones that were being represented by PSC attorneys.  This was his response:
"The Deepwater Horizon Claims Center processes claims as they are submitted. 
In the early stages of the process prior to the Fairness Hearing, and at the request of all parties, the Claims Administration Office had to select sample claims from each claim type that had the required and sufficient documentation to determine the accuracy of the claims process. 
Following this sample selection for the Fairness Hearing, claims are processed as they are received. " 

I replied and asked him exactly how many claims were used in the sample selection and what specific time period this sampling occurred.  I didn't receive a response as of my publishing this post. 

The Evidence

The first email exchange I received in the anonymous package is from PSC attorney Calvin Fayard to former Claims Office employee Christine Reitano with a carbon copy sent to Claims Administrator Pat Juneau.

ITEM 1:

Fayard email exchange request to expedite


As you can see the claim # is blacked out, so I am unable to identify what claim Fayard was asking to be expedited.  But note that Fayard says "Pat mentioned for members of the PSC to send along claim numbers for claims that have been filed and ARE LARGER (emphasis mine) claims that perhaps could be looked at more quickly."  Juneau then responds and orders Reitano to contact Brown and Greer with a request to expedite Fayard's claim.

ITEM 2:

The second email goes even further into the process and features directives dictated to the Claims Office by two PSC members, Steve Herman and Jim Roy:

Email exchange with Herman and Roy directives



The first directive in this email states that the Claims Office should only expedite three of the PSC members requested claims, across two or more claim types.

The second directive in this email is very interesting in that it orders the Claims Office to review and expedite roughly 24 claims across different claim types for six of the law firms that were considered major objectors at the time:  Rick Kuykendall, Sher Garner, Smith Stag, Farrel & Patel, Brent Coon and The Buzbee Law Firm.

It's not clear why Herman and Roy would have ordered the objectors' claims to be expedited along with their own but one possibility is that it could have been a tactic to eliminate these law firms' objector's status against the settlement.

I contacted three of the six objectors firms, two of them confirmed for me, off the record, that they were unaware their claims had been expedited.

One firm, Brent Coon, confirmed, on the record, that he was unaware any of his claims had been expedited.

After looking at the email exchange, Coon also called my attention to the relevance of the 3rd directive which orders the Claims Office to cease and desist reviewing the "class representative" claims (i.e., Lake Eugenie).  Apparently the PSC wanted to hold up these claims because if they were processed too early it would negate their ability to qualify as a "class rep claim".  Coon suggested that if the PSC had those claims sequestered without the consent of the claimants, that could be as big an issue as having their own claims expedited.

And I would also note Odom's curious response to the Herman and Roy directives:
"There was a question regarding item 3 of your email from the accountants.  Are they supposed to stop processing all claims for Class Representatives?  I assume this would be all of the PSC?  If so, what are the accountants supposed to tell the Class Representatives that have been calling them?  What happens to the claims?"
Directives 1, 2 and 3 in this email show a pattern by the PSC to manipulate the claims process as defined by the court.  The other interesting revelation of this email is that is demonstrates that the Claims Office was apparently taking directives from the PSC members with Pat Juneau's knowledge and consent.  It's not the PSC's role to give directives to the Claims Office.

ITEM 3:

The third email exchange contains an actual matrix from Brown and Greer of 409 claims per law firm and claim type that were expedited previous to September 27, 2012:

Email exchange with expedited claim matrix up to Sept. 27, 2012


 



That's 409 claims that were expedited for both the PSC firms and objectors (with at least three of them unaware this had happened).  There are obviously other law firms on the matrix but I have no idea why these particular law firms' claims were expedited.

In the email exchange, Bill Atkinson of Brown and Greer states that they didn't know which three claims to expedite for each objector (per the PSC request) so they just randomly chose the objectors' claims.  This would seem to validate the assertion by the objectors I spoke with that they had no idea that their claims had been expedited.

Sampling?

I suppose it is possible that these claims mentioned in the emails were expedited as part of the sampling process but that doesn't seem likely.  Please note I did not show Juneau the emails.  Had he agreed to the interview I would have shown them to him to get his immediate response.  I point this out to note that his response was not directly to the emails but the general question of whether or not claims, particularly PSC member's claims, had been expedited.  Also note that he never actually said claims had been expedited but his answer suggests some were for the sampling process alone.

The claims in these emails don't appear to be part of a sampling process and there is no mention of sampling associated with them in the email chain.  There are a number of other reasons the sampling suggestion wouldn't make sense.  I contacted two lawyers familiar with MDL claims processes (not associated with the DHECC) and they brought up the following points:

- The entire reason a Claims Administrator is appointed is to avoid having the PSC members calling the shots within the office.  The Administrator is supposed to be an unbiased arbitrator in the MDL process.  The fact that they selectively chose PSC firms' and objectors' claims to sample would not make sense and it's highly unlikely that BP would have agreed to this.  I suppose we'll find out if BP people read this post.

- The whole reason for conducting a sample in the first place is questionable considering Feinberg had already been processing claims in the GCCF for some time.

- Why were over 400 claims used for a sampling process and why were they specifically chosen from PSC filings?  It would make more sense to pull the first 10 to 20 claims from each claim type.  Plus, the PSC samples were most likely all accurate as they understood the filing requirements better than most.  This would tilt the sampling process negating the reason to conduct one in the first place.  The whole purpose of running a sample would be to discover potential problems.

- Juneau suggested the sample claims were pulled "in the early stages of the process" before the fairness hearing.  This fairness hearing did occur approximately one month (November 2012) after these emails exchanges but it seems unlikely they would be sampling claims in the 11th hour, four months after the Claims Office opened for business in June of 2012.  Also, if there was a sample that occurred, you would think Juneau should have reported the results in a spreadsheet to the Court and especially in preparation for the fairness hearing.  I haven't been able to find any such report (if anyone is aware of that report please contact me).

- Why did Calvin Fayard specify that the PSC members were allowed to expedite "larger" claims?  If you were conducting an accurate sample, it seems you would want all type of claims across the spectrum.

If all these claims were expedited for sampling purposes, the sampling process itself needs to be questioned.

A Blind Eye?

The revelations provided in the emails are not a surprise to me.  What is a surprise to me is that Special Master Louis Freeh hasn't addressed these issues.  He must have this email chain as he obtained Christine Reitano and David Odom's DHECC email databases during his investigation.  I must assume he is aware of the issues and he recognizes that they are a clear violation of the terms of the settlement.

In my opinion, these revelations are much more serious than the single claim, Thonn, that Freeh focused on in his first report.  I believe the issue he mentioned on page 60 of the first report is much more serious than the Thonn claim as well because it suggests actual fraud occurred in respect to the seafood claims....allegedly by an unnamed PSC firm.

In fact, expediting a claim (for the Andry Law Firm) is exactly the charge Freeh levied against Lionel Sutton.  Here we have 409 claims that were expedited, many for PSC members.  Is this not worthy of investigation?

The possibility for selective prosecution is of great concern here, as is the overall fiduciary duty to the class claimants by the PSC attorneys.  I believe these issues need to be addressed and explained by Louis Freeh, the PSC attorneys, Pat Juneau and in particular Judge Carl Barbier....they simply can't ignore this.

The Real Problem

The processing of claims has recently slowed to a near halt.  Many of the claimants who properly filed claims are now being asked to go back and meet new requirements that didn't exist at the beginning of the program.  IF PSC attorneys got their own clients paid ahead of other class claimants it is a clear fiduciary breach under MDL standards.

Many of the hard working people of the Gulf Coast...the shrimpers, the oyster fishermen....the people who have suffered the most from this disaster have yet to receive compensation while it appears these PSC attorneys have paid themselves first.  I'm going to introduce AZ readers to some of these folks down the road.

Contrary to Mr. LeCesne's opinion....I believe this is a very big deal.

Attribution note:  This website is under a Creative Commons license and any reference to this post and its material should follow the CC guidelines.

The entire email exchange referenced in this post can also be obtained at the following link but if republished it must be attributed to the American Zombie blog and/or "independent, investigative journalist, Jason Brad Berry":


http://www.scribd.com/doc/211748455/DHECC-Master-Email-Exchange-regarding-expedited-claims-of-PSC