Showing posts with label Herman and Herman. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Herman and Herman. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 13, 2014

The Wisner Trust - How deep do the conflicts run?

If you've followed the Wisner story here on AZ, you know that some members of the Plaintiff Steering Committee for the BP settlement also serve as a team of joint venture (JV) attorneys for the City of New Orleans and The Wisner Trust Advisory Committee in their litigation against BP for economic and environmental damages sustained by the 2010 oil spill.

The JV attorneys that are also on the PSC are Stephen Herman, Calvin Fayard Jr., Walt Leger and James Roy.  A fifth attorney, Fred Herman, is also a member of the JV group representing CNO and Wisner but he is not on the PSC.

These JV attorneys were initially hired by Mayor Landrieu to represent the City's interests in their claims against BP.  They subsequently took over The Wisner Trust Advisory Committee's case through what amounted to a hostile takeover of the Committee's board members thanks to Mayor Landrieu's back room maneuvers.  The Trust was initially being represented by the environmental law firm Waltzer and Wiygul but Landrieu claimed they should be replaced because they had a conflict of interest due to a lawsuit they had pending against the City regarding the Old Gentilly Landfill.

The Wisner heirs, wanting to remain with Waltzer and Wiygul, filed a complaint stating that the JV attorneys were themselves conflicted due to their role as the City's attorneys and even their role as PSC attorneys.

Federal Judge Carl Barbier ruled that it was ok for the JV's to represent both stating:
"The mere fact that the city and the donation may have different types of claims does not create an actual conflict.  Consequently, the court will grant the motion to substitute counsel. If at some future time an actual conflict arises, the court can address the matter at that time."
Perhaps that time is upon us regarding JV firm Herman and Herman.

Turns out senior partner, Russ Herman, has a pending lawsuit against the City of New Orleans over the proposed Tracage residential development in the Warehouse District.  Herman first filed a complaint with the City back in November of 2013 objecting to the height of the building among other grievances.

Since then he's filed a lawsuit against the City of New Orleans, his own client, (as well as the Tracage developers) in an attempt to block the building's construction.  The suit is Herman v. City of New Orleans and the docket # in Orleans Parish Civil District Court is 2014-896.

This is the exact reason the Mayor used to justify the removal of Waltzer and Wiygul as the Trust's attorneys against BP.  I would expect the Mayor is going to remove Herman and Herman as the City's counsel and Wisner's council any day now?  I ain't holding my breath.

As luck would have it, City Council moved to waive the conflict back in April of this year.  Jump to about 02:10:18 in the video.

That's convenient but what say Judge Barbier?

It's become brazenly clear in the past few months that the conflicts of interest with these guys are numerous and detrimental to both the City and the Wisner Trust.  It's also become brazenly clear they are not environmental lawyers and were not properly vetted to handle the Wisner case which at its core is an environmental lawsuit.

In a recent memo regarding complaints against BP for abandoning the clean up on Wisner Beach, BP seems to be keenly aware to the bogus claim the JV attorney's filed on behalf of the Orleans Parish Sheriff's Office for damages incurred to Wisner property from the oil spill.  As I pointed out in this post, OPSO has no interest in Wisner land and could not have incurred any economic loss in respect to Wisner.

BP recently referred to the claims mentioned in that post on page 5 of this legal filing.

Let us also consider that one of these JV firms serving on the PSC turns out to be the firm mentioned on page 60 of the first Freeh report....the firm that allegedly filed fraudulent seafood claims with the DHECC.  If that surfaces, does it become ammunition for BP and how would it affect the City and Wisner's claims against them?

Take it one step further and consider if these conflicts are possibly being used by BP to squeeze the JV attorneys on the City's case, Wisner's case or even in their role as PSC attorneys.

I don't have a law degree but I understand there's a damn good reason why potential conflicts of interest in litigation should be taken with the utmost scrutiny.  The conflicts that exist here could have a staggering monetary effect on both the BP settlement class the PSC/JV attorneys represent as well as the City and Wisner's litigation.

Wednesday, June 04, 2014

DHECC - Lionel Sutton Interview Part 3 - recipe for a zombie

In the third installment of the Lionel Sutton interview series, I’m going to focus on the investigation conducted by Special Master Louis Freeh which led to Sutton, his wife Christine Reitano, and the Andry Lerner Law Firm being accused of various criminal activity.   Specifically, we will examine how, in Reitano’s case, these allegations led to termination from the Claims Office.

Fraud    ...       

Before we get into the nuances of the "Freeh Style" investigation techniques, I want to show you a particular sound byte regarding fraudulent seafood claims.

Folks have criticized me for “burying the lead” in past posts, and I think they have a damn good point so let’s kick this post off with a bang:

Lionel Sutton - 15 - Page 60 - 2.mov from Jason Berry on Vimeo.

A disclaimer:  Lionel qualified this statement by saying he was not absolutely sure that this particular instance of fraud is what Louis Freeh was referring to on page 60 of his first report.  The only person who knows that, for sure, is Louis Freeh.  Unfortunately, it appears Freeh lost the scent and we may never know what firm he was talking about.  

Good news is it doesn’t matter.  Fraud has been alleged....now we all know.

Let me restate this revelation ….A plaintiff steering committee firm filed FRAUDULENT seafood claims....multiple.  After it was discovered by employees in the Claims Office it was brought to the attention of the Claims Administrator, Pat Juneau. 

According to Sutton, Pat simply told the firm not to do it again...a mere slap on the hand.  

This epiphany begs the question, "Were the fraudulent claims paid out even after it was brought to the attention of the Claims Administrator?" 

Unfortunately, we have no way of knowing that unless Juneau addresses the matter, publicly.  

Chew on this whole thing for a second....then let's take a look at the issues Freeh's first report addressed.

Lying liars who lie?

I think it's preposterous to assume Louis Freeh isn't aware of this PSC firm's fraudulent seafood claims.  And I can’t imagine Judge Barbier doesn’t know about it considering Sutton wrote it down in a memo of opposition his attorney filed with the Court. 

Understand this.....these falsified claims by the PSC firm are ILLEGAL.  

Please consider the gravitas here….a PSC firm used their knowledge of the claims process to manipulate and file false seafood claims.  This wasn't a simple scam to milk BP, it is detrimental to the other class seafood claimants.

Lionel explains why in this byte:  


If this allegation is true.....Juneau is absolutely complicit in a cover up.  Freeh is complicit if he doesn’t act against the firm.  Judge Barbier is complicit if he doesn’t demand that Louis Freeh make the allegations public and suggest criminal charges be brought against the firm in the same way Freeh did to Sutton and Reitano.

A disclaimer...

I know who the alleged firm is…at least the one Sutton is referring to in these sound bytes.  But that doesn't mean it's the same firm Freeh was referring to on page 60. 

I also know how the seafood claims were manipulated, in fact I expounded on it in this post.

I plan on revealing who this PSC firm is soon but I want to validate the story through one more source (the 4th) and I want to give the firm an opportunity to respond to the allegations.  I also have a standing request to interview Pat Juneau that has yet to be acknowledged.


Justice isn't Freeh

The real question mark that arises from this revelation is why would Freeh be protecting the PSC firm?  Why would Judge Barbier allow it?  Most importantly, was Louis Freeh really brought into the picture to actually conduct an unbiased investigation? 

Finally…has Freeh even come close to conducting an unbiased investigation?

The litmus test for those questions lies with Freeh’s charges against Christine Reitano more so than Lionel Sutton.  Sutton explains the allegations Freeh brought against Reitano in this byte, also, he talks about the evidence Freeh accrued to make the charges:

Lionel Sutton - -8 -Chrisitne and Mancuso.mov from Jason Berry on Vimeo.

To recap here, Freeh claimed Reitano knew her husband,  Lionel Sutton, was getting the referral fee on the Thonn claim and she then lied to his investigators about it under oath.  

Lionel states in this byte that Christine absolutely did not know about the referral fee because he never told her.

I know it's difficult to digest but if there's one thing I've learned from writing this blog, never assume a wife knows what a husband is doing...and vice-versa.  I can quote you  three husband/wife scenarios I've written about on this blog where this fact holds true....Bennett, Ellis, St. Pierre...Meffert.  OK, that's four....number five is forever grateful I stopped at four.  
                                                                               
Freeh also stated that Reitano was using her position at the Claims Office to negotiate a larger referral fee for Sutton with the Andry Lerner firm.  His basis for this statement was a phone conversation Reitano had with Andry Lerner attorney,  Christine Mancuso. 

Reitano vehemently denied this allegation after Freeh released his report.  In fact, even Mancuso denied the allegation Freeh made against Reitano.  

Here Sutton discusses how Freeh obtained the evidence to levy his allegations:

Lionel Sutton - 9 - Freeh no deposition, acct false accusation.mov from Jason Berry on Vimeo.

No actual affidavits or depositions were taken by the Freeh group in their investigation with the exception of Pat Juneau, Lionel Sutton and Christine Reitano.  Instead, the investigators "interpreted" the witnesses’ testimony.  

Now,  two of these witnesses have come forward to contradict the allegations made in the Freeh report.

Purgatory 

What’s more, Judge Barbier has denied the accused parties' request for discovery, including their ability to take their own depositions with the key witnesses:

Lionel Sutton - 11 - Not allowed discovery.mov from Jason Berry on Vimeo.

Not only has the Court denied the accused the right to discovery and due process, Barbier had Christine Reitano’s "breach of contract" lawsuit against the Claims Office (and BP) removed from civil court and into his own court.

There, it lies in limbo:

Lionel Sutton - 16 - Reitano issues and MDL.mov from Jason Berry on Vimeo.

Why would Barbier deny Reitano her civil rights and bury this case?  I humbly ask, "Does that constitute obstruction of justice?" 

They are being denied the right to face their accuser and question witnesses in order to argue their innocence.  How is that legal?  

A zombie?

In the next segment, I'll address impetus. Most notably why both Freeh and Judge Barbier seem intent on protecting the PSC firm that filed the fraudulent claims .  Also, why the Judge is denying Andry Lerner, Sutton…and most importantly, Reitano…due process.  





--> hounds kuzimu uchaguzi wako

Tuesday, March 11, 2014

DHECC - Proof positive of claims being expedited by the PSC

For the past year and a half I've been reporting on issues that have occurred with the BP oil spill multi-district litigation settlement and the Claims Office of the Deepwater Horizon Economics Claims Center (DHECC).

From the beginning, I was approached by multiple sources that made claims of fraud and manipulation within the DHECC process.  Most of the allegations involved issues that were instigated by members of the Plaintiff Steering Committee (PSC)....the lawyers chosen to represent all the class claimants along the Gulf Coast in their lawsuit against BP.

Typically...frustratingly..... almost every one of my sources refused to go on the record and I've had a difficult time providing hard proof of the allegations.

My luck changed last week.

Allegations

There are two main issues I've been researching regarding the misconduct of specific PSC members:

1.  The allegation that some PSC firms sold access to the claim "formula" before the claims office opened.  In fact, it now appears some of the PSC firms entered into joint venture agreements with other law firms around the Gulf Coast without disclosing the nature of their involvement to either the claimants or the claims office.

2.  That members of the PSC had their own private claims expedited before other claimants who had filed ahead of them.

The Rules of the Settlement

Before I get to the evidence, I want to point out again that by order of Federal Judge Carl Barbier, the claims which come into the DHECC must be processed in the order they are received:

10.  New claims may be filed during the Transition Process until such time as the Court Supervised Claims Program is established and operational as set forth above. New claims submitted shall be processed and evaluated in the order they are received. Non-deficient claims previously pending with the GCCF shall be processed and evaluated prior to any new claims filed after the creation of the Transition Process.

A Breach of the Settlement?

Last week, I received an unmarked envelope in the mail that contained a series of email exchanges between employees of the Claims Office and other DHECC officials.  Among those involved in the conversation included Claims Administrator Pat Juneau, court vendor Brown and Greer, and members of the PSC.

These emails clearly suggest that PSC members were not only expediting their own claims, they were actually issuing directives to the employees of the Claims Office.  In fact, it looks like they were even holding back specific claims from being processed for political reasons.

Keep in mind the PSC lawyers are supposed to be representing all the claimants in this settlement process, not just their own personal clients.

Trying to get answers

A year ago in March of 2013, I filed a FOIA request with the DHECC in an effort to find out if any PSC members had expedited their own claims within the office.  My request was denied:

A little help

After the denial, I drafted a personal letter to Judge Barbier asking him to redact claimants' private information and make the claim data public so the public could be assured the process was operating according to the standards he had ordered:

The DHECC - Examining the "Claims" - Part 1

Judge Barbier never responded to my letter.

I made contact today with the Claims Office and requested an interview with Claims Administrator Pat Juneau.  My interview request was denied but he did agree to provide statements and facts to any questions I had.  I responded by asking him (via email) if he was aware of any claims that may have been expedited in the office, particularly ones that were being represented by PSC attorneys.  This was his response:
"The Deepwater Horizon Claims Center processes claims as they are submitted. 
In the early stages of the process prior to the Fairness Hearing, and at the request of all parties, the Claims Administration Office had to select sample claims from each claim type that had the required and sufficient documentation to determine the accuracy of the claims process. 
Following this sample selection for the Fairness Hearing, claims are processed as they are received. " 

I replied and asked him exactly how many claims were used in the sample selection and what specific time period this sampling occurred.  I didn't receive a response as of my publishing this post. 

The Evidence

The first email exchange I received in the anonymous package is from PSC attorney Calvin Fayard to former Claims Office employee Christine Reitano with a carbon copy sent to Claims Administrator Pat Juneau.

ITEM 1:

Fayard email exchange request to expedite


As you can see the claim # is blacked out, so I am unable to identify what claim Fayard was asking to be expedited.  But note that Fayard says "Pat mentioned for members of the PSC to send along claim numbers for claims that have been filed and ARE LARGER (emphasis mine) claims that perhaps could be looked at more quickly."  Juneau then responds and orders Reitano to contact Brown and Greer with a request to expedite Fayard's claim.

ITEM 2:

The second email goes even further into the process and features directives dictated to the Claims Office by two PSC members, Steve Herman and Jim Roy:

Email exchange with Herman and Roy directives



The first directive in this email states that the Claims Office should only expedite three of the PSC members requested claims, across two or more claim types.

The second directive in this email is very interesting in that it orders the Claims Office to review and expedite roughly 24 claims across different claim types for six of the law firms that were considered major objectors at the time:  Rick Kuykendall, Sher Garner, Smith Stag, Farrel & Patel, Brent Coon and The Buzbee Law Firm.

It's not clear why Herman and Roy would have ordered the objectors' claims to be expedited along with their own but one possibility is that it could have been a tactic to eliminate these law firms' objector's status against the settlement.

I contacted three of the six objectors firms, two of them confirmed for me, off the record, that they were unaware their claims had been expedited.

One firm, Brent Coon, confirmed, on the record, that he was unaware any of his claims had been expedited.

After looking at the email exchange, Coon also called my attention to the relevance of the 3rd directive which orders the Claims Office to cease and desist reviewing the "class representative" claims (i.e., Lake Eugenie).  Apparently the PSC wanted to hold up these claims because if they were processed too early it would negate their ability to qualify as a "class rep claim".  Coon suggested that if the PSC had those claims sequestered without the consent of the claimants, that could be as big an issue as having their own claims expedited.

And I would also note Odom's curious response to the Herman and Roy directives:
"There was a question regarding item 3 of your email from the accountants.  Are they supposed to stop processing all claims for Class Representatives?  I assume this would be all of the PSC?  If so, what are the accountants supposed to tell the Class Representatives that have been calling them?  What happens to the claims?"
Directives 1, 2 and 3 in this email show a pattern by the PSC to manipulate the claims process as defined by the court.  The other interesting revelation of this email is that is demonstrates that the Claims Office was apparently taking directives from the PSC members with Pat Juneau's knowledge and consent.  It's not the PSC's role to give directives to the Claims Office.

ITEM 3:

The third email exchange contains an actual matrix from Brown and Greer of 409 claims per law firm and claim type that were expedited previous to September 27, 2012:

Email exchange with expedited claim matrix up to Sept. 27, 2012


 



That's 409 claims that were expedited for both the PSC firms and objectors (with at least three of them unaware this had happened).  There are obviously other law firms on the matrix but I have no idea why these particular law firms' claims were expedited.

In the email exchange, Bill Atkinson of Brown and Greer states that they didn't know which three claims to expedite for each objector (per the PSC request) so they just randomly chose the objectors' claims.  This would seem to validate the assertion by the objectors I spoke with that they had no idea that their claims had been expedited.

Sampling?

I suppose it is possible that these claims mentioned in the emails were expedited as part of the sampling process but that doesn't seem likely.  Please note I did not show Juneau the emails.  Had he agreed to the interview I would have shown them to him to get his immediate response.  I point this out to note that his response was not directly to the emails but the general question of whether or not claims, particularly PSC member's claims, had been expedited.  Also note that he never actually said claims had been expedited but his answer suggests some were for the sampling process alone.

The claims in these emails don't appear to be part of a sampling process and there is no mention of sampling associated with them in the email chain.  There are a number of other reasons the sampling suggestion wouldn't make sense.  I contacted two lawyers familiar with MDL claims processes (not associated with the DHECC) and they brought up the following points:

- The entire reason a Claims Administrator is appointed is to avoid having the PSC members calling the shots within the office.  The Administrator is supposed to be an unbiased arbitrator in the MDL process.  The fact that they selectively chose PSC firms' and objectors' claims to sample would not make sense and it's highly unlikely that BP would have agreed to this.  I suppose we'll find out if BP people read this post.

- The whole reason for conducting a sample in the first place is questionable considering Feinberg had already been processing claims in the GCCF for some time.

- Why were over 400 claims used for a sampling process and why were they specifically chosen from PSC filings?  It would make more sense to pull the first 10 to 20 claims from each claim type.  Plus, the PSC samples were most likely all accurate as they understood the filing requirements better than most.  This would tilt the sampling process negating the reason to conduct one in the first place.  The whole purpose of running a sample would be to discover potential problems.

- Juneau suggested the sample claims were pulled "in the early stages of the process" before the fairness hearing.  This fairness hearing did occur approximately one month (November 2012) after these emails exchanges but it seems unlikely they would be sampling claims in the 11th hour, four months after the Claims Office opened for business in June of 2012.  Also, if there was a sample that occurred, you would think Juneau should have reported the results in a spreadsheet to the Court and especially in preparation for the fairness hearing.  I haven't been able to find any such report (if anyone is aware of that report please contact me).

- Why did Calvin Fayard specify that the PSC members were allowed to expedite "larger" claims?  If you were conducting an accurate sample, it seems you would want all type of claims across the spectrum.

If all these claims were expedited for sampling purposes, the sampling process itself needs to be questioned.

A Blind Eye?

The revelations provided in the emails are not a surprise to me.  What is a surprise to me is that Special Master Louis Freeh hasn't addressed these issues.  He must have this email chain as he obtained Christine Reitano and David Odom's DHECC email databases during his investigation.  I must assume he is aware of the issues and he recognizes that they are a clear violation of the terms of the settlement.

In my opinion, these revelations are much more serious than the single claim, Thonn, that Freeh focused on in his first report.  I believe the issue he mentioned on page 60 of the first report is much more serious than the Thonn claim as well because it suggests actual fraud occurred in respect to the seafood claims....allegedly by an unnamed PSC firm.

In fact, expediting a claim (for the Andry Law Firm) is exactly the charge Freeh levied against Lionel Sutton.  Here we have 409 claims that were expedited, many for PSC members.  Is this not worthy of investigation?

The possibility for selective prosecution is of great concern here, as is the overall fiduciary duty to the class claimants by the PSC attorneys.  I believe these issues need to be addressed and explained by Louis Freeh, the PSC attorneys, Pat Juneau and in particular Judge Carl Barbier....they simply can't ignore this.

The Real Problem

The processing of claims has recently slowed to a near halt.  Many of the claimants who properly filed claims are now being asked to go back and meet new requirements that didn't exist at the beginning of the program.  IF PSC attorneys got their own clients paid ahead of other class claimants it is a clear fiduciary breach under MDL standards.

Many of the hard working people of the Gulf Coast...the shrimpers, the oyster fishermen....the people who have suffered the most from this disaster have yet to receive compensation while it appears these PSC attorneys have paid themselves first.  I'm going to introduce AZ readers to some of these folks down the road.

Contrary to Mr. LeCesne's opinion....I believe this is a very big deal.

Attribution note:  This website is under a Creative Commons license and any reference to this post and its material should follow the CC guidelines.

The entire email exchange referenced in this post can also be obtained at the following link but if republished it must be attributed to the American Zombie blog and/or "independent, investigative journalist, Jason Brad Berry":


http://www.scribd.com/doc/211748455/DHECC-Master-Email-Exchange-regarding-expedited-claims-of-PSC

Sunday, March 09, 2014

The Wisner Trust: Horse trading in Louisiana's wild, wild justice system

It was recently brought to my attention that the Wisner heirs had filed a complaint with the U.S district court, Eastern District of Louisiana in respect to the five JV attorneys hired by Mayor Mitch Landrieu to represent The Wisner Trust Advisory Committee in their case against BP for the damages inflicted upon Wisner properties during the 2010 Macondo oil spill.

I received that complaint last week.   Apparently it has already been dismissed by Federal Judge Sarah S. Vance:

Complaint against JV attorneys representing Wisner Trust v. BP

The five law firms I refer to as the "JV (joint venture) attorneys" are: Herman, Herman & Katz; Domengeuax, Wright, Roy & Edwards; Fayard & Honeycutt; Fred Herman and Leger & Shaw.  Three of these firms...Herman, Roy and Fayard....also serve on the Plaintiff Steering Committee for the Deepwater Horizon Economic Claims Center.

These JV attorneys also represent The City of New Orleans as well as Orleans Parish Prison in their lawsuits against BP.

Keep in mind that public entities are not allowed to enter the settlement program (DHECC), only private individuals.  Public claims against BP for the oil spill must be filed in open court.

The Great Wisner Train Robbery

For over a year, AZ has documented the shenanigans that occurred with the Wisner Trust Advisory Committee and how Mayor Landrieu, along with his appointee to the Trust, Michael Sherman, manipulated the five-seat committee in order to create a "hostile takeover":

American Zombie: The Wisner Fund - Battle for the Bayou - Part I

American Zombie: The Wisner Fund - Battle for the Bayou - Part 2

Immediately after two Mayoral cronies, Anthony Lorino for Tulane and Ron Gardner of LSU, were placed on the board by their respective entities; Michael Sherman called a vote to fire the Trust's existing legal counsel in their case against BP and replace them with the aforementioned JV attorneys.  Having the majority three-man vote needed to pass a motion, Sherman, Lorino and Gardner succeeded in their plan to fire the environmental law firm Waltzer and Wiygul in order to bring the JV attorneys on board.

After over a year of documenting this story, I've uncovered so many conflicts of interest with the JV attorneys and falsifications by City attorneys, specifically former Executive Counsel to the Mayor, Michael Sherman......it's difficult to keep up with them all.

In respect to conflict of interest issues, the most notable was in Part 2, when I posted an email chain between Sherman, Steve Herman and BP attorneys, Mark E. Holstein and  Nathan Block.  There, Herman was providing Holstein and Block with privileged information from a Wisner Trust Advisory Committee executive session.  Keep in mind....this is the plaintiff attorney providing the defense's attorney with privileged information from the claimant.  I'm not sure how a conflict of interest gets any more explicit than that and it's right there in black and white.

And the obfuscation and dissembling has continued even after Sherman quietly resigned his position as a city attorney to seek the brights lights of show business as an on-air legal analyst for WDSU (officially making him a public figure).

Indeed, the Mayor's counsel won a major victory in Orleans Civil District Court, per Ad Hoc Orleans Civil District Court (CDC) Judge Melvin Zeno, partially on the premise that The Wisner Trust Advisory Committee should have no oversight on the City's portion of the Wisner proceeds because an oversight body already existed in City Council.  Sherman's successor to the Wisner trustee postion, Erica Beck, sat through the entire hearing listening to her colleague, City Attorney Sharonda Williams, make the City Council oversight argument to Judge Zeno in order to avoid oversight from the Advisory Committee.

One month later Beck stood in front of City Council and told them no one in the Mayor's office envisioned City Council having oversight over the Wisner funds:

American Zombie: What wicked webs we weave...

One of the biggest revelations the blog uncovered was a complaint filed in may of 2013 against BP by the JV attorneys on behalf of the Orleans Parish Sheriffs Office (OPSO).  In that complaint, the JV attorneys claimed the Sheriffs Office had suffered economic losses, per taxes, because of the damage to Wisner property:

American Zombie: "Complaints"

1.  In item 31 of the Wisner complaint this grievance for OPSO is listed:  "...including New Orleans, was a foreseeable result of the oil spill. The adverse impacts to these industries resulted in reduced economic activity in New Orleans which is heavily dependent on the seafood, tourism and petrochemical industries. Due to the foreseeable adverse impact on these industries, the Sheriff of Orleans has lost, and continues to lose, ad valorem property tax revenues and other taxes."

The only problem with that is that there is no Wisner property in Orleans Parish.  This claim is fraudulent...pure and simple...and it was filed by the JV attorneys.

If you read the comment section of that post, you will see an exchange I had with an anonymous commenter who claimed the inclusion of Wisner in the Orleans Parish Sheriffs Office complaint was simply a "cut and paste" error.  A simple mistake on behalf of the law firm that filed it.  That would be a potentially multi-million dollar cut and paste error but the commenter assured me this happens all the time.

I'm curious if the legal filing was retracted or amended since last May....if not....it's still fraudulent... and it's still pending in Orleans Parish CDC.

I also noted that a "loss of natural resources" from Wisner land was claimed on behalf of the City and OPSO but was curiously absent from the Wisner claim filed by the JV attorneys:

Item #2  

Why would they fraudulently file a claim for OPSO in respect to Wisner while downplaying losses for the Wisner Trust, itself?  Let me provide a thesis.

Art of the horse trade:  

a clever and often secret agreement made by powerful people who are usually trying to get an advantage over others

Getting back to the Wisner heirs complaint filed with U.S district court, Eastern District of Louisiana  and the items within it I found to be of the greatest significance...the main problem with the JV attorneys representing the City, OPSO and Wisner is the potential for them to "horse trade", as Wisner heir Michael Peneguy refers to it on Page 28, item # 20 of the complaint.  The scenario being that the JV attorneys could be using the Wisner settlement as leverage to increase the amount on other settlements they are representing such as the City's or OPSO's:


After having followed this story for over a year, I believe this is exactly what is happening.  Keep in mind that any money awarded to Winser by BP has very strict guidelines in how it must be spent...but not so with the City.

In filing this complaint with  the U.S district court, Eastern District of Louisiana against the JV attorneys, the heirs hired University of Mississippi law professor, Benjamin Cooper, to offer a legal opinion on the possible conflict of interest issues.  In his affidavit, he offers the opinion that a conflict does indeed exist with bullet points to that effect in items 10 -12 on pages 10 through 13:

Click on the pic to expand or refer to the original document
These bullet points tellingly reflect Mayor Landrieu's MO with the Wisner Trust Advisory Committee since he took office and first placed Michael Sherman as his appointee.  Herman and Herman attorney and the point person for the JV attorneys on Wisner, Soren Giselson, echoes the Mayor's mantra perfectly, "...the ultimate decision-making authority should rest with the Mayor, as Trustee".

Waltzer and Wiygul were originally hired by the Committee after an extensive vetting process to find an environmental law firm that would have the best understanding of the damage incurred to the Wisner property from the BP spill.  Shortly after Sherman was appointed and the Committee was politcally stacked, W&W was then inexplicably removed at Sherman's suggestion and replaced with the JV attorneys.

But even with the crony votes on the Committee (Lorino and Gardner) following orders to approve the hiring of the JV attorneys the move was not congruent with Rule 1.0(e) of the Louisiana Rules of Professional Conduct regarding "Informed Consent" which states:
(e) “Informed consent” denotes the agreement by a person to a proposed course of conduct after the lawyer has communicated adequate information and explanation about the material risks of and reasonably available alternatives to the proposed course of conduct.   
In items 18 - 20 Cooper details how not only did they JV lawyers fail to obtain the required waiver from the Committee, they admitted that a potential conflict could exist due to their existing joint representation with the City of New Orleans in its case against BP.  However, they failed to explain to the Committee what that potential conflict may be.

Cooper also details how the JV attorneys presented the Committee with a proposed contract in the 11th hour, one day, before the September 25, 2012 meeting in which they were being asked to vote on its approval.  Cooper argues that there was no possible way the entire Committee could have vetted the JV attorneys' contract or sought outside legal advice as to their potential conflicts of interest within that 24-hour time frame.

Nonetheless, in that meeting Michael Sherman, Anthony Lorino, and Ron Gardner provided the 3 votes needed to contract the JV attorneys with the heirs and the Salvation Army casting the two minority dissenting votes.

Basically, the JV attorneys were steam-rolled in as the new counsel to replace Waltzer and Wiygul.  Later on in the complaint...we get a pretty good idea why.

In item number 23 on page 18, we discover that the JV attorneys created a contingency fee arrangment within their contract.  Cooper points out that under LRPC 1.5 (a), a lawyer "shall not make an agreement for, charge, or collect an unreasonable fee...".  He later points that there is almost no chance of the Donation not being able to recover a substantial damage amount and that even Soren Giselson has publicly acknowledged as much.  The Donation could have easily paid attorneys on an hourly basis and considering most of the leg work had already been accomplished by Waltzer and Wiygul the addition of a contingency fee is most likely inappropriate in this case.

He also points out that even though the heirs have requested the details of the contingency fee, the JV attorneys have failed to provide them.  Which brings me to a final point, independent of the complaint filed with the U.S district court, Eastern District of Louisiana.

There's only one Marshall in this town

Months ago, the heirs stopped receiving update statuses from the Wisner Field Inspector on the ongoing effects of the BP oil washing in on Wisner property.  Michael Peneguy contacted the Field Inspector by email asking why the update statuses had stopped.  The Field Inspector replied that he was told by JV attorney Soren Giselson to stop sending updates to the Advisory Committee.  After further inquiry by Peneguy to Giselson, City Attorney and current Mayoral appointee to the Advisory Committee, Erica Beck, informed Peneguy that she had instructed Giselson not to reply to him because she didn't want to "jeopardize the Committee's position with respect to its BP claim."


So understand this...Beck is ordering the JV attorneys not to share information with the Wisner Trust Advisory Committee....the counsel's clients.  Apparently the clients don't have the right to see information held by their attorneys in their own lawsuit.

This isn't surprising though if you look at the objectives of the Mayor and the JV attorneys.  The mayor believes the entire Trust is his...or rather the City's.  Actually I can't tell which.  The Lens calls actions like this being a bully (read the comment section)...the TP dutifully polished the turd and called it political hardball....other people call it being a productive asshole.

I call it not only unethical but quite possibly illegal.

The government, court and media roundup?

Both times I visited Wisner Beach, In February and October of 2013, to document the constant barrage of oil washing onshore there was a backlash from the Mayor's office towards the heirs for allowing me on the property.  The first trip I took in February resulted in Michael Sherman creating a "media policy" where the Advisory Committee would have to approve anyone wanting to visit the beach.  But Sherman didn't seem to think he needed Committee approval when he went on camera with John Snell of Fox 8.  Snell and Fox 8 had their cameras on the beach the same day I did.  (The beginning of that Snell story looks vaguely familiar does it not?)

Any rational legal person may look at this evidence and think at the very least there is an obvious malpractice suit waiting in the wings.  But the Mayor, his City attorneys and the JV attorneys may have even lassoed that bucking bronc....remember the City is now claiming that the heirs were never actually heirs to begin with.  Even though Ad Hoc Judge Zeno handed the mayor most everything he wanted in the hearing without much legal explanation, he refrained from ruling on the matter of the heirs' standing.  If the court decides the heirs aren't really heirs...they can't file a malpractice suit can they?

I recently made a post about "The $ Estate".  What I mean by The $ Estate is that I believe there are a a select few people within the city that have enough power and money to control all four estates of our democracy: executive, legislative, judicial and the press.  The three basic branches of government speak for themselves in this matter but the influence these power brokers have over the fourth estate, the press, may be a little harder to see.

If you scrape the surface, it reveals itself.  

I find it curious that the Times-Picayune's "Louisiana Purchased" series focused on politicians and campaign bundling but left Mayor Landrieu out of the fray.  I did point out back in February of 2013, a year ago, that three of the JV attorneys contributed at least 10%, possibly as high as 15% or more, of Mayor Landrieu's campaign contributions for 2012 through campaign bundling.  Herman and Herman alone accounted for approximately $71,000 of $755,882.

I guess it never occurred to the TP to look at the Mayor's campaign contributions.  I wonder why?

Seems like the $ Estate is truly above the justice system, eh?  Well....maybe not.  Stay tuned to AZ this week, cowpokes...this rodeo could get interesting.  


Monday, January 27, 2014

Barbier....judge or magician?

...because apparently he has a knack for making prickly things disappear.

Funny thing happened today.  The very day federal court opened for business after I referenced this Motion for Leave to Class Counsel's Comments on the Special Master's Report over the weekend, Judge Barbier struck the Class Counsel's comments on the Freeh Report filed on Sept 20, 2013 from the record:

 Barbier order to strike CC comments on Freeh Report Sept. 20, 2013

I guess maybe the judge had forgotten about it and the BP motion to leave jogged his memory? Regardless, by striking the CC comments it now renders BP's motion for leave....and the issues I brought up in my post....moot.

Also... now special master Freeh doesn't have to be made "officially" aware of the issues.  Of course if he reads AZ he would be unofficially made aware of the client referral and law firm partnering issues but I'm sure he's way too busy to stop by here.

I said it had slipped under the radar but now it's like it was never even a blip!

I'm sure this is all just a coinkydink....and a swell turn of events for some.

Herman, Herman and Katz and those PSC attorneys....how lucky can you be?  It's like they made a deal with Ol' Scratch down at the crossroads.



UPDATE - COMMENT BUMP:

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Barbier....judge or magician?": 

What a coincidence. The AndryLerner supplemental objection to the Freeh Report was also withdrawn today. That opposition was just filed on January 17 and was the only opposition from any of those parties that dealt specifically with the joint representation / fee split issues. There was even an opinion attached from a well respected ethics expert but that was withdrawn also. In fact, the motion to withdraw and the order made certain that the exhibit was identified and withdrawn. I'm sure you can find a copy of that order.

What could possibly have caused AL to withdraw an opposition that they just filed a week earlier. I'm sure that the ethics expert and the accounting expert that was also included were not cheap. Andry did not withdraw his opposition. Lerner did not withdraw his opposition. The other AndryLerner oppositions were not withdrawn. Only the opposition dealing with the joint representation issue.

I don't know about AZ, but this is too much of a coincidence for me. And if its not a coincidence, what was the quid pro quo?

Well...yeah...if that's true it is way too much of a coincidence and then you have to ask was there some kind of deal cut with Andry Lerner to drop their supplemental objection.  Basically, in one day the entire issue was wiped off the radar...off the record that is. 

I would like to see that order if anyone can find it. 

It certainly appears as if Barbier is waving his magic scepter to hide the potential indiscretions of Herman, Herman & Katz and the PSC lawyers in general.  

Saturday, January 25, 2014

DHECC - A BP motion that slipped under the radar

I am falling way behind on posts because my real world jobs and responsibilities are taking precedence but there is a lot going on in the BP claims world.

By now most people have seen the motion for recusal by Kurt Mix's attorneys to remove Judge Duval from his case.  Judge Duval had filed a an economic loss claim against BP without disclosing it to the court.  This only adds to Judge Duval's woes as the latest Freeh report seems to be targeting his son David's actions within the claims office and also calls into question how David was hired at the office in the first place.  I have reason to believe Magistrate Judge Sally Shushan may have also played a role in influencing Claims Office Administrator Patrick Juneau to hire David Duval.

It's not clear if David Duval used his position at the claims office to benefit claims filed by his family's law firm but lots of rumors are swirling.

While all of this is unfolding, Freeh's autonomy and integrity are also being called into question by the Andry law firm, Christine Reitano and Lionel Sutton...the accused parties in Freeh's first report. Wednesday Andry filed a motion to have Freeh removed as Special Master with both Sutton and Reitano joining that motion today.  As I write this, I believe Judge Barbier has denied that request but I haven't seen the official denial.

BP also filed a letter to Barbier requesting much of the evidence used to levy the allegations against Andry Lerner, Reitano, and Sutton.

These are all significant issues but there is one issue I want to focus on in this post that passed completely below the radar.  One week ago today, on Jan. 17th, BP filed a Motion for Leave to Class Counsel's Comments on the Special Master's Report.  What I want to point out in this report is item number 3:

Class Counsel note that Louisiana Rule of Professional Conduct 1.5(e) does not specify the time when the client’s written consent to a fee-sharing arrangement must be obtained. See Cmts.   3. Yet a practice of obtaining client consent to a shared representation “at different times” after the commencement of the representation would defeat the purpose of Rule 1.5(e) and thus should be strongly discouraged. The obvious aim of Rule 1.5(e) is to protect the client’s right to select counsel of his choosing before legal services are provided. The practice of obtaining consent to shared representation at later or different times lends itself to abuse, as the client may not know who is handling his case until well after services have already been provided. In In re Fewell, cited by Class Counsel (Cmts.   3 n.11), the Louisiana Attorney Disciplinary Board stated that “[o]bviously, it is prudent for such writings to occur at the commencement of the representation.” No. 12-DB-048 (La. Discip. Bd. Aug. 7, 2013) at 8, available at http://www.ladb.org/new/DR/handler.document.aspx?DocID=8027. The Disciplinary Board further found that the client had been informed in advance of all lawyers who would represent him and consented to the shared representation. Written consent to the representation by all lawyers in a fee-sharing agreement should be obtained at the outset of the representation and before legal services are provided. Class Counsel further suggest that express client consent to the share of the fee that each lawyer will receive in a fee-sharing agreement may not be required. See Cmts. ¶ 3 n.11. Louisiana Rule 1.5(e)(1), however, provides that fee division is permissible only if “the client agrees in writing to the representation by all of the lawyers involved, and is advised in writing as to the share of the fee that each lawyer will receive.” Since the choice of lawyers at all times Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-SS Document 12180-2 Filed 01/17/14 Page 3 of 10

I'm not sure if I'm interpreting this correctly but I think it may confirm an issue I've been working on for the past couple of weeks regarding one specific PSC firm, Herman, Herman & Katz.

I've been informed that Herman, Herman & Katz created "fee-sharing" agreements with multiple law firms across the Gulf Coast at the onset of the DHECC.  Allegedly, they created an arrangement where the partnered law firms would submit their client's claim information to Herman, Herman & Katz who would then file the partnered firm's claims for them, under the partnered firm's name.  I'm not sure what the advantage to the partnered firms would be other than to possibly have their claims expedited by Herman, Herman & Katz within the claims office or to perhaps ensure their claims were not rejected.

I've spoken with a couple of attorneys regarding this issue and I'm still not sure if it is illegal but as BP suggests it is highly unethical.  The partnerships could create a scenario where the partnered firms' clients may not know they are being represented by Herman, Herman & Katz and more importantly it creates a scenario where the claims office, itself, may not know Herman, Herman & Katz was involved in the submittal of the claims.

This may not seem like a huge deal at first glance but the complications that arise with the overall evolution of the DHECC claims process can get pretty hairy.

For example, remember that the seafood claims are a capped fund so any money left over in that fund will be distributed pro rata to the claimants who received claims.  Depending on the extent to which a single firm, especially a PSC firm, has partnered with other law firms around the Gulf they may have a significant, if not a majority, interest in the seafood claims submitted unbeknownst to the claims office.  As you can imagine, if this PSC firm held any influence over which seafood claims were approved or denied, they could potentially be manipulating the claims process to their advantage by ensuring their firm's claims and their partnered firms' claims were approved while other claims were denied.  When all the claims are processed they could reap a substantial benefit with the pro rata payout without the claims office even knowing the PSC firm had partnered with the other firms.

There is even the potential for collusion among the PSC firms to ensure the above scenario unfolds.

This also ties back in to my original FOIA request to the DHECC where I asked for a list of the claims filed in the first four weeks of the claims office opening.  If you recall I had received reports that the PSC firms' claims had been pushed ahead of other claims and also that at least one PSC firm may have sold access to the "formula" of the claims process before the office opened.  The possibility that a PSC firm may have sold access to partnerships on top of the shared percentages upon payout also exists.

I've also been informed that the latest Freeh report was in fact a "preliminary" report to an upcoming more comprehensive report.  I still don't know if Freeh is going to reveal the identity of the page 60 law firm...a PSC firm....but it doesn't seem likely.     

Wednesday, October 30, 2013

It's time to take Mayor Landrieu on his word regarding the oversight of Wisner Trust Funds

In my post on the Wisner hearing I noted that Sharonda Williams, New Orleans City Attorney, made an argument to Judge Zeno that there was no need for the Wisner Trust Advisory Committee to serve as an oversight body to how the Mayor spends the Wisner funds because there is already a check and balance system in place.  She suggested that oversight body is New Orleans City Council.  

I found it to be a specious claim the moment I heard it but apparently Judge Zeno took her word and granted the Mayor full control of the City's portion of the Wisner funds.

In fact, he apparently took the city attorneys' word on everything,  even going so far as cutting and pasting part of their counter-motion into his own "judgement".  That cut and paste job was just about the only explanation he provided in any of his rulings which gave Mayor Landrieu practically everything he asked for.

I was pretty sure the City Council claim was a smoke screen when I heard it but I wanted to check and see if City Council members were aware that the Mayor's office considered them to have any oversight with the City's portion of the Wisner funds.

I spoke with two City Council members about the issue, Stacy Head and Susan Guidry.

Councilperson-at-Large, Stacy Head, told me she had looked into the matter back in February and had asked the Assistant Fiscal Officer to the Council, David Gavlinksi, to do the same.

Councilperson Head forwarded me an email chain between her, Gavlinski and City Council President, Jackie Clarkson.  I condensed the messages into this document according to date:

City Council Email Thread on regarding the Wisner Trust 2013

This is what the municipal code states in respect to the Council's involvement with the Wisner funds:
DIVISION 4. – EDWARD WISNER DONATION ADVISORY COMMITTEE
Sec. 2-159. - Function.

Subject to the control and direction of the council, the powers, duties and functions of
the Edward Wisner Donation Advisory Committee shall be the supervision, direction
and administration of all of the lands, funds and avails constituting and comprising the
Wisner donation, or the avails or fruits thereof, and to consult with and advise the mayor in his capacity as trustee upon all matters pertaining to such trust and the mayor when acting upon the advice of the committee, or a majority thereof, shall be deemed to be acting for and in behalf of all the parties at interest. To that end all matters relating to the trust shall in the first instance be referred to and handled by the committee.  (Code 1956, § 19-4) 
Gavlinski goes on to offer an opinion (not legally binding mind you, just an opinion) of City Council's role with the Trust:
Of interest is a section on page six of the attached, which reads:

“… the Mayor of the City of New Orleans, with the approval of the Commission
Council (or its successor body), may act as such Trustee upon the advice and
with the consent of the majority of said Commissioners, and such action, so
authorized, shall be binding on all parties hereto.”

My reading of that is that the Mayor, on behalf of the City, has but one vote
on the committee. That vote is subject to approval of the Council, and must
accompany a majority of the committee member. I’m fairly certain that this is a
level of restraint that has not occurred over the years as any Mayor has seldom
come to any Council for their “approval.”
I think what he's saying is the law states City Council does have legal oversight but it was never actually put into practice.

Soooo...note to City Council:  The Mayor is ultimately subject to the oversight and approval of City Council on all matters regarding Wisner.

In fact, his lawyers just made that exact argument in Zeno's court.  They claimed that they shouldn't have to answer to The Wisner Trust Advisory Committee because they are already legally bound to answer to City Council....Zeno agreed.

The problem is City Council had no idea that they were responsible.  At least the two At-Large members on the Council didn't know, as evidenced in this email chain.  Nor did the third councilperson I spoke with, Susan Guidry.

I'm not criticizing the council members in any way for not knowing this, they are elected officials that came into their jobs following the practices of the council members before them.  The modus operandi and annual budget agenda never included a breakdown of The Wisner grant money.

I believe Gavlinski states as much in his response to the council members after researching the matter:
"It appears as if we have nearly a century of operational inertia whereby the
Council has not appropriated all the funds, even though this practice may
be contrary  powers in the above referenced code. Alas, the Mayor may be
right in one respect, but it seems clear that the fund has operated outside of
complete Council authority in the past.

I believe that historically, there has been more harmony between the chair
of the Committee and the rest of its membership, so this issue may have not
arisen as acutely. " 
Apparently, the issue never came up until now.  Regardless, once again, here's a note to City Council: YOU ARE THE OVERSIGHT BODY.  In fact City Council is now the ONLY oversight body.  The Mayor's counsel just lobbied this admission in a court of law....and the judge agreed.  

I suppose the person we should consult is the Special Counsel to the City Council.  I'm sure that appointee could provide an objective legal opinion on the matter, eh?  Because whoever holds that position would not be privy to the mayor in any way, eh?

As luck would have it, the City just accepted RFQs for that position and four law firms applied.  I'll give you three guesses as to who one of those firms is and the first two don't count.


Funny stuff, huh?  The one critical position with City Council that is supposed to be objective and independent of the executive branch of city government (the Mayor's office) and Herman and Herman are applying for it.  I'm sure there's no conflict of interest there...nah....

...seeing as how they are representing the City and the Wisner Trust in their settlement case against BP...

....seeing as how Herman and Herman members and family members comprised the single largest bloc of campaign contributions to Mayor Landrieu in 2012...

....no....no conflict here.....Where's that Uddo or Zeno opinion when you need it?